When is a local patch more than a patch? I got thinking about this somewhat academic question last fall as I found myself in a good-natured eBird competition with a very sharp teen birder who also had a Concord patch on eBird. I finished the year with 161 birds, but he found over 170. Both of us were intensively birding some reliable patches, and then assembling them into a larger town "patch." It begs the question of what a patch really is, but the aggregate patch concept intrigued me as a potential tool for pulling in disparate sightings for a relatively small geographic area. After all, what if my list were combined with his list—what would we have seen "together?"
Many aspects of the eBird database are virtual, not least of which are top-100 lists, recent sightings apps like BirdTrax, the species mapping tool, and so forth. So the question eventually presented itself: what might Ludlow Griscom have made of eBird if he were doing his famous study, Concord Birds, now? One of the amazing things to me about his book was how he gathered sightings of his own and other birders into an aggregate representation of status and distribution of birds in the Concord area since the turn of the 20th century. Is it always accurate? Certainly not, but it is always suggestive, and Griscom preserves many amazing sightings from otherwise lost field lists of long-dead birders.
How would Griscom have assembled his data today? eBird suggests itself as the logical tool for a relentless, competitive, highly-networked birder like Griscom. At the heart of the eBird concept is, essentially, patch-listing, and I think this concept eludes many birders using it. At Plum Island, a current and somewhat notorious example, eBirders have placed hundreds of personal location markers for their sightings, some on top of established hot spots, some at nearly random locations along the island, many representing single sightings. If you run a recent sightings report from Plum Island, a Western Grebe might appear anywhere on the island, or only at Lot 1 ocean. Compare the often chaotic eBird reporting with Tom Wetmore's meticulous Plum Island Sightings page and you see how dividing Plum Island into useful patches can really work. Similarly, Griscom talked about the birds of Concord with real specificity, citing sightings by patch locations: Nine Acre Corner, Great Meadows, Fairy Land, Fairhaven Bay, Merriam's Corner, and so forth.
Since my Concord patch list is assembled from many of the same locations that Griscom used, why not see what Griscom could have gathered by aggregating field lists from local patch birders? And why not have some fun, too? Enter Ludlow G. and his crowd-sourced Concord Big Year, 2013.
I hope you will join in the fun by keeping up with Ludlow and allowing him to shadow you in the field this year. The challenge is 200 species, but also exploring potential patches which we tend to avoid, well, because tradition says they don't have birds. Yes they do!
Saturday, January 19, 2013
Monday, January 7, 2013
He's Everywhere!
Our man Ludlow G. has had a busy first week in his virtual 2013 Concord Big Year, and has birded with some good company, including Cole Winstanley, David Sibley, Lucas Hale, Chuck Johnson, Willy Hutcheson, Connie Schlotterbeck, Gian Fabbri, and Will Martens, Kathy Dia, and the rest of the Great Meadows weekly survey crew.
If we had any doubts about what the great man might be like in his Web 2.0 incarnation, he's an inveterate lister, twitcher, and die-hard eBirder. You see it, and he's there. He has had a hankering to see the Gyrfalcon, but he's sticking to the rules (although he cheated and went for Canvasbacks at Fresh Pond).
This week he spent a lot of time at Kaveski Farm looking at sparrows, redpolls, and looking for shrikes with several parties. He saw a Wood Duck on Jan. 1 and a continuing Rufous Hummingbird at a private residence (he knows people who know people); he's also seen Pine Grosbeaks and Common Ravens at Middlesex School.
As of this morning, Ludlow is at 55 species in Concord, not bad for a newly-plugged-in old timer!
Thanks to all who have contributed to the project. The hope is to explore all the nooks and crannies of Concord through many eyes and reach 200 species.
Tuesday, January 1, 2013
Concord Birds 2013 Begins!
Happy 2013!
Ludlow G. and the Concord Birds 2013 Project began today with a good bird, a resplendent drake Wood Duck in the Assabet River below Cousin's Field.
Here are Ludlow G's first shared sightings:
Cousins Park/Thoreau School Neighborhood, West Concord, MA, Middlesex, US-MA
Jan 1, 2013 8:00 AM - 9:00 AM
Protocol: Traveling
0.5 mile(s)
Comments: Windy, 30*, warm front pushing in.
19 species
Wood Duck 1 loosely associating with Mallards just below Cousin's Field in the Assabet; flew upstream toward Damon Mill. Observed for 5 minutes
Mallard 5
Red-tailed Hawk 1
Mourning Dove 1
Red-bellied Woodpecker 1
Downy Woodpecker 2
Blue Jay 4
American Crow 8
Black-capped Chickadee 4
Tufted Titmouse 1
White-breasted Nuthatch 2
Carolina Wren 1
American Robin 5
American Tree Sparrow 3
Dark-eyed Junco (Slate-colored) 1
Northern Cardinal 1
House Finch 1
American Goldfinch 13
House Sparrow 15
Share your 2013 Concord sighting with Ludlow G. at davidswain79 at gmail.com. Our crowd-sourced goal is 200 species.
all the best in 2013!
Ludlow G. and the Concord Birds 2013 Project began today with a good bird, a resplendent drake Wood Duck in the Assabet River below Cousin's Field.
Here are Ludlow G's first shared sightings:
Cousins Park/Thoreau School Neighborhood, West Concord, MA, Middlesex, US-MA
Jan 1, 2013 8:00 AM - 9:00 AM
Protocol: Traveling
0.5 mile(s)
Comments: Windy, 30*, warm front pushing in.
19 species
Wood Duck 1 loosely associating with Mallards just below Cousin's Field in the Assabet; flew upstream toward Damon Mill. Observed for 5 minutes
Mallard 5
Red-tailed Hawk 1
Mourning Dove 1
Red-bellied Woodpecker 1
Downy Woodpecker 2
Blue Jay 4
American Crow 8
Black-capped Chickadee 4
Tufted Titmouse 1
White-breasted Nuthatch 2
Carolina Wren 1
American Robin 5
American Tree Sparrow 3
Dark-eyed Junco (Slate-colored) 1
Northern Cardinal 1
House Finch 1
American Goldfinch 13
House Sparrow 15
Share your 2013 Concord sighting with Ludlow G. at davidswain79 at gmail.com. Our crowd-sourced goal is 200 species.
all the best in 2013!
Friday, December 21, 2012
Birds of Concord: Crowd-Sourcing a Big Year with Ludlow
On January 1, 2013 a virtual birder will be joining eBird. His name is Ludlow G., and he will be a virtual field observer of every bird encountered in the town of Concord during 2013. Being a bit old school, Ludlow doesn't own a computer (even though he enjoys being a avatar), but he certainly understands the value of a database that contains effort details, links to photos and sound files, and that can be mined for data on status and distribution. After all, he wrote the seminal book, Birds of Concord (1949), using this approach.
On behalf of Ludlow, I will be accepting all shared eBird lists and non-ebird sightings in the town of Concord and entering them on his behalf during the year. His goal is typical Ludlow, a modest 200 species, which he figures is possible given that several locals have northwards of 160 in 2012 and life lists over 190 in Great Meadows alone. Ludlow is a bit flexible in how he defines town lines; if he can throw a stone from the town line and reach the location, it's in. This brings in School Street fields, Kaveski Farm, Hanscomb at Virginia Rd. Locals will know; out-of-towners can ask. So, let's do a local Big Year with Ludlow! In honor of the man and the book, share your sightings and let's see what he can find!
Share your sightings with davidswain79 [at] gmail.com.
Go Ludlow!
Thursday, December 20, 2012
Northern Lapwing (Finally)
Over the past month I have agonized over all the sightings of Lapwings that arrived in Massachusetts in the wake of Hurricane Sandy and associated weather systems. The bird in Bridgewater alone remained to taunt me, and today I finally was clear enough from the semester and endless grading and family obligations to go down and see it. Driving along Summer St., I spotted a pullout with a car by a corn field and figured this must be it. I pulled up, looked to my right, and saw the lapwing, not 50 feet away. As I got out, ambling up the road was the inimitable and indefatigable and helpful Bob Lessard, who has directed countless twitchers to the bird and daily checks on its status. Here's to you, Bob!
There were also two Harriers working the fields, an adult male, and this "pumpkin" juvenile.
There were also two Harriers working the fields, an adult male, and this "pumpkin" juvenile.
Monday, October 22, 2012
Snow Goose, Great Meadows Concord, Oct. 22, 2012
A handsome Snow Goose dropped by Great Meadows NWR in Concord, MA this morning during the weekly survey.
Tuesday, July 17, 2012
2012 AOU Checklist Supplement
Time for guidebook authors to shuffle the deck again.
The AOU has just published its 53rd Supplement to the Checklist. Of most interest is that the AOU has moved the falconiformes (caracaras and falcons) and psittaciformes (parrots) to a pivotal position between Picidae (Woodpeckers) and Tyrannidae (Tyrant Flycatchers).
Yup, right before passerines. As the Supplement notes, "recent phylogenetic analyses of mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequences have shown that the Falconiformes, Psittaciformes, and Passeriformes form a monophyletic group" (Chesser et al., p. 578).
Here are some more detailed summaries by Paul Hess and Rick Wright.
The AOU has just published its 53rd Supplement to the Checklist. Of most interest is that the AOU has moved the falconiformes (caracaras and falcons) and psittaciformes (parrots) to a pivotal position between Picidae (Woodpeckers) and Tyrannidae (Tyrant Flycatchers).
Yup, right before passerines. As the Supplement notes, "recent phylogenetic analyses of mitochondrial and nuclear DNA sequences have shown that the Falconiformes, Psittaciformes, and Passeriformes form a monophyletic group" (Chesser et al., p. 578).
Here are some more detailed summaries by Paul Hess and Rick Wright.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





